Miss West Virginia Teen USA winners have placed 12 times at the MISS TEEN USA Pageant. Highlighted are our winners and their placements at the national pageant:

• Olivia Travis (2024): 4th Runner-up

• Trinity Tiffany (2018): Top 15

• Olivia Hutchison (2017): Top 15

• Lexsey Marrarra (2014): Semifinalist

• Haley Holloway (2013): Second Runner-up

• Elizabeth Sabatino (2012): First Runner-up

• Susan King (2011): Top 15

• Chelsea Welch (2007): Fourth Runner-up

• Andrea Turner (2005): Second Runner-up

• Heather Gray (1996): First Runner-up

• Wendy Stephens (1988): Top 10

• Jodi Caldwell (1986): Top 10

Miss West Virginia Teen USA winners have won two Special Awards at MISS TEEN USA:

• Miss Congeniality: Cora King (2020)

• Best State Costume: Kelly Porterfield (1985)

The Miss West Virginia Teen USA Hall of Fame includes:

1. 1983 – Kay Scadden

2. 1984 – Trina Vertillo

3. 1985 – Kelly Porterfield

4. 1986 – Jodi Caldwell (Top 10)

5. 1987 – Cheryl Cullop

6. 1988 – Wendy Stephens (Top 10)

7. 1989 – Jennifer Dunn

8. 1990 – Mindy Green

9. 1991 – Tracey Rexroad

10. 1992 – Kelly Humphreys

11. 1993 – Jennifer Pringle

12. 1994 – Jonelle Spiker

13. 1995 – Sarah Russell

14. 1996 – Heather Gray (First Runner-up)

15. 1997 – Amanda Burns

16. 1998 – Erica Bevins

17. 1999 – Carrie Fleshman

18. 2000 – Ginneene Barone

19. 2001 – Tara Szersen

20. 2002 – Heather Estep

21. 2003 – Whitney Veach

22. 2004 – Mary Ellen Wolfe

23. 2005 – Andrea Turner (Second Runner-up)

24. 2006 – Lora Gallagher

25. 2007 – Chelsea Welch (Fourth Runner-up)

26. 2008 – Micah Michael

27. 2009 – Alysia Marie Thompson

28. 2010 – Ally Brandfass

29. 2011 – Susan King (Top 15)

30. 2012 – Elizabeth Sabatino (First Runner-up)

31. 2013 – Haley Holloway (Second Runner-up)

32. 2014 – Lexsey Marrarra (Semifinalist)

33. 2015 – Cora King (Miss Congeniality)

34. 2016 – Cassy Trickett

35. 2017 – Olivia Hutchison (Top 15)

36. 2018 – Trinity Tiffany (Top 15)

37. 2019 – Brennah Groves

38. 2020 – Sophia Martino

39. 2021 – Brylee Knotts

40. 2022 – Emma Kitchen

41. 2023 – Lakyn Campbell

42. 2024 – Olivia Travis (Fourth Runner-up)

Four Miss West Virginia Teen USA's have also won the Miss West Virginia USA title and competed at Miss USA. They include:

1. Haley Holloway: Miss West Virginia Teen USA 2013 (2nd Runner-up at Miss Teen USA) and Miss West Virginia USA 2019

2. Chelsea Welch: Miss West Virginia Teen USA 2007 (4th Runner-up at Miss Teen USA) and Miss West Virginia USA 2013 (Top 15 at Miss USA 2013)

3. Whitney Veach: Miss West Virginia Teen USA 2003 and Miss West Virginia USA 2011

4. Amanda Burns: Miss West Virginia Teen USA 1997 and Miss West Virginia USA 1999